Green Groups Hit CA Decision Favoring Garbage Dump in Manila Bay-Obando, Say Decision to Worsen Climate Change Impacts in the Area

Quezon City. As the world prepares for the Global Climate March come September 21, green groups denounce a court decision favoring the operation of a privately-owned garbage dump in the Manila Bay – Obando area, an area that is highly susceptible to the impacts of climate change.

Early last week, stories of the Court of Appeals decision giving the green light for the resumption of the construction and operation of the much criticized 45-hectare Obando Sanitary Landfill hit the news. The landfill is being built in a mangrove forest area in Manila Bay, in a coastal fishing village in flood-prone Obando, Bulacan.

“The CA made a bad decision that boggles the mind in many respect. While we have much to talk about in disagreement with the CA decision, a more pressing concern now is that the ruling will greatly exacerbate the impacts of climate change in the highly vulnerable town of Obando and the entire Manila Bay,” said Aileen Lucero, National Coordinator of EcoWaste Coalition, a broad zero waste advocacy alliance.

“The solution to our growing garbage crisis is clearly not the creation of more dumps, such as landfills, as this merely delays massive contamination of the environment and debilitates the capacities of the affected communities, but the genuine enforcement of R.A. 9003,” Lucero added.

EcoWaste Coalition maintained that Republic Act 9003, the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act, is very clear in its mandate to enforce ecological solid waste management to divert wastes from ending up in dumps, through segregation at source, reusing, recycling, composting, listing and prohibition of non-environmentally acceptable products, and establishment of materials recovery facilities. If properly done, this will reduce wastes greatly, making landfill operations economically unviable.

Cheen Layman of Obando Kami ay Para sa Iyo (OKAPI), one of the local groups in Obando actively opposing the landfill, also assailed the ruling, saying, “the CA decision virtually sentenced us to death, as it will adversely affect the livelihood of thousands of fishing families in Obando – Malabon – Navotas area and seriously disturb the remaining mangrove forest and breeding grounds of sea life, weakening the people’s capacities against extreme climate events.” 

For his part, Paeng Lopez of the Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives said that “landfills are the largest global source of human-created methane, a toxic climate-changing gas that is 25 to 72 times more potent than carbon dioxide, thereby contributing immensely to climate change.”

Flooding is prevalent in the area even without extreme weather events, and dislodging sea water by a 45-hectare landfill would worsen the flooding, at the same time, exposing the affected communities to catastrophic health and environmental risk ‘time bomb’ that could be triggered by extreme weather events and similar occurrences, such as an earthquake, the groups noted.

In October 2011, in response to a query by the EcoWaste Coalition, PHIVOLCS Director, Renato Solidum, stated that Obando is susceptible to a host of weather and climate-related events, such as flooding, storm surges, even liquefaction, earthquake, and tsunami.

A published study by Kelvin Rodolfo and Fernando Siringan also point out that the Manila Bay area is susceptible to waves as high as 3.7 meters brought about by mere southerly winds, such that even the US Navy declared the bay an unsafe haven during typhoons.

The concerned area in Manila Bay is, at present, the site of the mountain-like 45-hectare Navotas Sanitary Landfill, towering above the remaining mangroves around it and “stinking like hell,” as one lead figure in Obando described it. During the early 2000s, the same area became the home of the Navotas Controlled Disposal Facility until its operation was forcibly stopped by a river barricade set up by the people of Obando to prevent garbage-carrying barges from reaching the dump area.

Recently, during the grilling of Environment and Natural Resources Secretary, Ramon Paje, over the perennial trash in Manila Bay, Senator Legarda similarly observed that “Manila Bay is becoming the garbage dump of three regions around Manila.”